Film versions of musicals are inherently problematic for this reviewer. While able to suspend disbelief for many film requirements, it's just hard to accept people breaking out  into singing as they require. Still, upon watching "FIDDLER ON THE ROOF," it's easier to appreciate when a film musical works well. Director Norman Jewison's adaptation of the long-running play, somehow transcends most film musical limitations. From the opening number, "TRADITION," and throughout, it's obvious some new things are being tried out here. Having the lead character speak to the camera(audience) was somewhat new for a film musical at the time. Jewison's attention to detail with the editing around this scene is remarkable, and the way in which the community is introduced is really impressive, and a great demonstration as to how a film can "open up" the comparable stage production to a wider canvas.

While there are cinematic devices that annoy as much as please, overall, the story of Tevye and his challenges at keeping his wife happy, while contending with the maturation of his children, poverty and a potential pogrom around every corner, has been masterfully carried over to film by Jewison, and it's entertaining to watch, and easy to revisit, at least to see and hear select moments.  Some of the songs, "IF I WERE A RICH MAN" are quite memorable, and while running at 3 hours, it feels a tad long, its scope and epic feel make the length understandable.

FOX/MGM has provided the correct 2.35:1 aspect ratio for this AVC MPEG-4 1080p blu-ray.  Although the intentionally soft look given to most of the imagery due to various lensing, can be grating after a while, this transfer is a flawless representation of how it was designed to look in theaters.  Colors veer towards being quite vibrant in most scenes. Detail, even with a soft, gauze-like sheen to various scenes, is typically outstanding. Minor scratches pop up, but are never intrusive.

FOX/MGM has provided a DTS-HD MA 7.1 mix!  Although this lossy mix is used best when enhancing the terrific score, as rendered by John Williams(Yes, "that" John Williams), surrounds and discrete effects are handled effectively in creating an immersive, if not aggressive environment. There are minor instances wherein limitations of the original mix elements are obvious, but for the most part, this mix is terrific!

Most of the extras found on the most recent dvd edition of this film, have been carried over. Unfortunately, none are in HD.

A commentary with the director and Topol, offers some interesting stories, but becomes dry, about an hour into it.

Other featurettes explore the actresses playing Tevye's daughters, a deleted song, the score,  and more! Also, of course, the dvd of the film is also offered.